Posts Tagged ‘Hans-Hermann Hoppe’

Concerning Estoppel

Saturday, April 26th, 2014   Submitted by Christopher Zimny

EstopleArgumentation ethics or communication ethics does not establish what is morally right or wrong, it only establishes what is the case. For instance, the praxeological theorem of exchange shows only what happens when two actors trade goods; it does not say this is a morally good thing (at least in an objective sense). The praxeological theorem of theft (in the economic sense, not the ethical sense) states only the conditions under which theft can take place. It does not say or prove that theft is a morally bad thing.

(more…)

Ultimate Foundation of Private Property, Part 2: Presuppositions of Communication

Thursday, April 24th, 2014   Submitted by Christopher Zimny

EstopleIn Part 1 I disputed the foundation on which Hans-Hermann Hoppe builds his argument ethics. Because his argument is based on the implications of argumentation itself, his argument leaves no room for recognition of ownership by actors who do not argue with one another. In Part 2, I will review these points, but focus mainly on reconstructing Hoppe’s argument using the basic act of communication, rather than the act of argumentation itself.

Thus, let us begin.

(more…)

Ultimate Foundation of Private Property, Part I: Argumentation Ethics

Friday, December 20th, 2013   Submitted by Christopher Zimny

ArgumentEthicHans-Hermann Hoppe claims to have discovered the ultimate foundation of property rights in an argument that he calls “argumentation ethics”. (For two essays by Hoppe on this topic, see here and here.) The goal of his argument is to show what social norms must be considered valid prior to debate about any other social norms. This is an admirable undertaking, and he succeeds in showing exactly what norms all arguments necessarily presuppose. His argument captured the admiration of his mentor, Murray N. Rothbard, who called it “a dazzling breakthrough for political philosophy,” and it sparked a fiery debate since its original publication in 1988, which still continues among libertarian circles today.

(more…)

Daily Anarchist

           Supporters of